Which Ohio Medicaid Plan Is Best for 2027?

Which Ohio Medicaid Plan Is Best for 2027?

Ohio gives Medicaid members seven health plans to choose from, but most of what those plans cover is identical. Since October 2022 every Ohio Medicaid plan has used the same pharmacy manager and the same drug list, and the state sets the core benefits all seven must offer. So the decision is narrower than seven brochures suggest. For most people it comes down to one question (are my doctors in this plan?), and for a few specific groups, one or two extras that really do differ.

Open enrollment runs November 1–30, 2026. Any member can switch during that month, and the new plan starts on the first day of the following month. If you're happy where you are, you don't need to do anything.

What doesn't change when you switch: your prescriptions (one statewide drug list, run by Gainwell Technologies for every plan), the benefits the state requires every plan to cover, and your child's OhioRISE behavioral health enrollment, which the state says is not affected by your plan choice. You also keep your Medicaid eligibility. Plans don't decide who qualifies.

The seven plans for 2027, and how the state grades them

All seven plans that served Ohio Medicaid in 2026 are in the state's 2027 comparison guide, so nobody is being forced off a plan this year (unlike Louisiana, where Healthy Blue is leaving). What most members never see is the state's own report card. The Ohio Department of Medicaid rates each plan from one to five stars in four areas, and the scores spread out more than you'd expect.

PlanAccess to careEase of using planSpecialized careMember experience
AmeriHealth Caritas Ohio3.54.02.03.0
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield2.02.51.53.0
Buckeye Health Plan3.02.52.53.5
CareSource3.53.03.03.5
Humana Healthy Horizons2.54.03.03.5
Molina Healthcare4.03.03.53.5
UnitedHealthcare Community Plan2.52.52.53.5
Source: Ohio Department of Medicaid, Managed Care Plan Comparison 2025 (Medicaid Health Plan Report Card). Star ratings out of 5. "Specialized care" covers dental care, opioid use disorder treatment and quitting tobacco.

Two results stand out. Molina has the best scores in access to care and specialized care and ties for the top in member experience. Anthem, the best-known name on the list, is lowest or tied for lowest in all four categories. That doesn't make Anthem the wrong plan for you. If your doctors are in Anthem and not elsewhere, that matters more than half a star. But brand recognition isn't a reason to pick it.

Step one: your doctors decide most of it

Networks are the biggest real difference between Ohio's plans. Not every plan contracts with every hospital system, specialist group or community health center, so if you see a doctor regularly, start there. Use the state's Medicaid Consumer Hotline site ("Find a Provider") or call each office and ask which Ohio Medicaid plans they take. Check your primary care doctor, any specialist you see, and the hospital you'd go to.

If only one or two plans include everyone you need, you're done. Everything below is for breaking ties. If your doctors take all seven, or you don't have regular doctors yet, the extras below are where the plans actually differ.

If you're an adult who needs glasses

This is the biggest difference between plans that most people overlook. Ohio's base benefit for adults 21 to 59 is one eye exam and one pair of glasses every 24 months. Several plans do better:

PlanExtra vision benefit for adults 21–59 (2027 guide)
Molina$0 exam, glasses, frames and lenses every 12 months, all ages
HumanaEye exam every 12 months; up to $200 per year for one pair of glasses or contacts
Anthem$100 per year toward glasses or contacts and fitting
AmeriHealth Caritas$150 per year toward contact lenses; extra exams for adults 21–50 with diabetes
UnitedHealthcareExam every 12 months; $150 per year toward contacts; $25 toward frames and lenses
CareSource$100 toward contacts and fitting every two years
BuckeyeNo co-pays on exams or eyewear; $50 toward contacts plus $50 fitting every two years
Source: Ohio Medicaid MCO Health Plan Comparison (2027 guide, updated July 1, 2026), pages 4 and 6.

If your prescription changes often, or you break glasses, Molina's yearly pair and Humana's $200 a year are worth far more than the base benefit. Dental, by contrast, hardly differs. The base benefit is one adult cleaning a year, and every plan adds a second one (more on what Medicaid dental covers in our dental guide).

If you're pregnant or planning to be

Every plan covers prenatal care and keeps mom and baby covered for 12 months after delivery. The differences are in the rewards, which are paid as gift cards or reward cards for going to visits you'd go to anyway:

Rides matter in pregnancy too. AmeriHealth Caritas, CareSource, Humana, Molina and UnitedHealthcare all list unlimited trips for prenatal and postpartum appointments on top of their regular ride allowance. Anthem and Buckeye don't list that extra in the 2027 guide.

If you're an adult who'll have to meet the 2027 work rule

This is the new factor for 2027. Starting January 1, 2027, most Ohio Medicaid expansion adults (Group VIII, ages 19–64) will have to show 80 hours a month of work, school, job training or volunteering, and renew every six months instead of every year. (Who's exempt and how reporting works are covered in our work requirements guide and our six-month renewal guide.)

Your plan doesn't decide whether you meet the rule. The state and your county do. But some plans offer real help with the things that count toward those 80 hours:

If you're one of the adults who'll be reporting hours in 2027, these perks can tip a tie toward Anthem or CareSource. That cuts against the report card for Anthem, so weigh which matters more to you.

If you don't have a car

Ohio's base benefit only covers a standard ride when the nearest in-network provider is at least 30 miles away. Every plan adds non-medical and short-distance rides, but the size of the allowance differs. AmeriHealth Caritas and Anthem give up to 30 round trips a year, double the 15 round trips offered by Buckeye, CareSource, Humana, Molina and UnitedHealthcare. Those trips can cover grocery stores, food banks, WIC and county caseworker meetings, which matter more in 2027 with renewals every six months.

If your child gets intensive behavioral health care

Pick based on your child's other doctors. OhioRISE, the state program for kids with complex behavioral health needs, is run by Aetna Better Health of Ohio for every plan, and the state's guide says your plan choice doesn't affect OhioRISE eligibility or enrollment. The same goes for medications. Since every plan uses the same drug list, switching plans won't change which prescriptions are covered.

How to switch

During November 1–30, 2026, you can change plans three ways:

Your new plan starts on the first day of the month after you choose. Pick a primary care doctor for each family member when you enroll, or the plan will assign one. Outside November you can only switch in your first three months on a plan, or for "just cause," meaning you've tried to get care through your plan and still can't.

Sources: Ohio Medicaid Consumer Hotline — Next Generation Medicaid FAQ; Ohio Medicaid Consumer Hotline — Change Plans; Ohio Medicaid Single Pharmacy Benefit Manager.

Frequently asked questions

Will switching plans change which medicines are covered?

No. All Ohio Medicaid plans use one statewide drug list managed by Gainwell Technologies. The only exception is drugs given in a doctor's office, which your plan handles directly.

If I switch in early November, when does the new plan start?

The first day of the next month, so a November choice starts December 1. Use up any calendar-year extras you've earned on your current plan before then, and ask the new plan how its yearly limits apply to a December start.

Do I have to pick a plan during open enrollment?

No. If you do nothing, you stay on your current plan for 2027.

Can a plan help me keep Medicaid under the work rule?

A plan can't exempt you or report hours for you. The state and county decide that. Some plans offer job coaching, childcare help, tutoring or rides that make it easier to log qualifying hours.

Not sure you still qualify for Ohio Medicaid?

Ohio covers adults up to 138% of the federal poverty level, or $22,025 a year for a single adult in 2026. Check your household's limit before you renew.

See Ohio's Medicaid income limits →

This article reflects the Ohio Department of Medicaid's 2027 plan comparison guide (updated July 1, 2026) and its most recent report card, as of October 31, 2026. Plans can change their extra benefits during the year. Confirm details with the plan or the Ohio Medicaid Consumer Hotline before you switch. This is general information, not personalized insurance advice. Already unsure whether you're enrolled? See how to check if you have Medicaid.